Austria,International ( calls for electoral reforms at EU level

2 Nov , 2018  

Ahead of the European elections in May 2019, ( highlights the electoral reform process at European level and underlines the benefits of international and citizen election observation. ( explained the details in a guest commentary in the Wiener Zeitung on 2 November 2018: (Wahlreformen gefordert – Wiener Zeitung Gastkommentar pdf download)

The European Parliament elections are one of the biggest democratic events in the world. In May 2019, some 340 million citizens are eligible to vote to elect the 705 Members of the European Parliament, thereby directly determining the future of the European Union. However, the electoral system is in need of reform. The conduct of the European Parliament elections is governed not by European law but by national legislation. Technically speaking, the European Parliament elections in 2019 are 27 individual elections for one joint representative body. Depending on the country, the election may differ in terms of active and passive suffrage rights, electoral system, election threshold, voting age, election day(s), deadlines for registration of candidates and voters, eligibility rules, among other issues.

In order to harmonise the conduct of European Parliament elections and counteract low voter turnout through “Europeanisation”, a majority of Members in the European Parliament voted in favor of electoral reforms in November 2015. The European Council, however, after two and a half years agreed only to a few areas of reforms. The implementation of the reform proposals faced difficulties, as the Member States are obliged to decide unanimously and some reforms require constitutional changes in some EU member states.

As a tool to continually improve electoral practice, regular observation and evaluation of the European elections based on international standards and good practices would be desirable. The Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE/ODIHR) monitored the European elections in 2004 and 2009 and formulated recommendations for the further development of the European electoral law. In order to make this possible, as well as for the implementation of other electoral reforms, a sufficient degree of political will is needed. Although all EU countries have signed the Copenhagen Document of the OSCE (1990), which obliges participating States to invite OSCE observers and accredit citizen observers, many EU countries are defaulting on implementation (see article). According to OSCE/ODIHR reports, only four EU Member States (Croatia, Finland, the Netherlands, Romania) have so far provided a sufficient legal framework for international and national election observation.

There is need for electoral reforms at the European level, not only in harmonising the electoral conduct in all EU member states but also in terms of implementing international commitments. Election observation could be used as tool to support the necessary legislative and political reform processes at the European level and in the Member States.