Democracy Promotion Abroad, Barriers at Home? Our new paper unpacks the East–West gap in election observation

·

A new article titled “Democracy promotion abroad, barriers at home? The East–West gap in the recognition of citizen election observers across the European Union” by Election-Watch.EU’s colleagues Markus Pollak, Paul Grohma, and Armin Rabitsch has been published in Frontiers in Political Science. 

The study addresses a critical paradox: while the European Union actively champions democracy and election monitoring globally, a majority of its own Member States fail to legally recognise and facilitate domestic citizen election observers at home. 

The research draws on empirical data collected during Election-Watch.EU’s Election Assessment Missions (EAMs) for the 2019 and 2024 European Parliament elections, triangulated with findings from OSCE/ODIHR missions.

Democratic conditionality in the EU

Across the EU, only 9 out of 27 Member States explicitly recognise domestic election observers in their electoral law, while 16 out of 27 recognise international election observers. The data reveals a strong asymmetry: while 8 out of 13 “new” Member States (EU13) provide a legal framework for citizen observation, only 1 out of 14 “old” Member States (EU14) do so.

 

This divergence can be explained through the mechanism of democratic conditionality. Newer Member States adopted observer-friendly legislation to meet OSCE standards as part of the accession criteria for joining the EU, at a time when citizen election observation had become a consolidated international norm. Conversely, older Member States joined before this standard was established and faced no subsequent external pressure to update their domestic laws, resulting in long-standing institutional inertia. 

Our recommendations

The paper outlines three key recommendations to create opportunities to close these legal gaps and enhance the EU’s democratic credibility: 

  1. Introduce legislation to recognise and accredit citizen election observers: Member States should establish a clear legal framework governing the accreditation of citizen election observers, essential to safeguard the integrity and credibility of electoral processes. Transparent and codified accreditation procedures protect electoral integrity while enabling Electoral Management Bodies to distinguish independent observers from partisan or deceptive “shadow” groups.
  2. Introduce legislation to recognise and accredit international election observers: Candidate frameworks should eliminate blurred or arbitrary divides between citizen and international observers in legal frameworks, grounding accreditation in objective standards of independence and professionalism rather than formal categories.
  3. Ensure accreditation procedures comply with democratic principles and cover the full electoral cycle: Accreditation systems must be non-discriminatory, transparent and legally grounded, protecting the electoral process from manipulation by partisan actors while ensuring that genuine citizen election observers can contribute to democratic accountability.

Access the full paper here.